Judging Rubric

Criteria	What to Look for While Judging – Scientific Research Projects	Points
Scientific Thought	Scientific Thought: 1. Question or problem was stated clearly and unambiguously 2. The procedure/methods were well thought out and organized 3. Data and results were presented using quantifiable numbers and statistical analysis 4. Lab notebook/logbook is complete with original data, dates, & notes 5. Variables & Controls are clearly recognized and used appropriately 6. The student/team understands their project’s tie to related research	30
Creative Ability	1. The project showed creative ability and originality in: • The question asked • The approach to the problem • The interpretation of the data	25
Thoroughness	1. Adequate data were collected to support the conclusions 2. Conclusions are based upon multiple trials, replications and/or test subjects 3. The student/team is aware of other theories or approaches 4. Conclusions and/or data analysis describe possible errors or flaws 5. Background research is related to the project and summarized by the student 6. References are identified 7. The student/students allowed themselves enough time to perform a thorough investigation 8. TEAMS ONLY: Each member of the team has made a clear, outlined contribution to the project and is familiar with all aspects of the project	20
Skill	1. The student/team demonstrated that they have the required laboratory, computation, observational and design skills necessary to have completed their project 2. The student/team may have received help and assistance but the completed project reflects their work and understanding 3. The written material reflects the student/team’s understanding and research	15
Clarity	1. The important phases of the project are presented in an orderly manner 2. There are few or no spelling and grammatical errors 3. Data and results are presented clearly	10
		100
Total Points Possible